Torch vs Electric: ComboJoy Whiskey Smoker Kit vs a Butane-Free Electric Smoker

The ComboJoy Whiskey Smoker Kit is the best-selling torch kit on Amazon. The electric whiskey smoker is the new-school answer: no butane, no flame in your hand, and a 0–60 second timer. Same goal, smoky whiskey. Very different ways to get there.

Short answer: ComboJoy if you want the complete gift box, the ritual and the most proven option. Electric if you want push-button convenience and don’t want a torch anywhere near your bar.

Head-to-head specs

Specs per the listings at time of writing. Double-check what’s bundled before you buy.

Round 1: Convenience — Electric wins

No gas to buy, no torch to fill, no lighting ritual. Set the timer, let it run, lift and sip. The ComboJoy isn’t hard, but it’s more steps, and it’s dead in the water if you forget the butane.

Round 2: Safety — Electric wins

There’s no open flame in your hand and no butane can on the shelf, which matters if you’ve got kids around, a tight apartment or friends who get “creative” after round three. The torch kit is safe when used right, but it’s still a flame next to alcohol.

Round 3: Smoke intensity and control — ComboJoy wins

The timer is great for consistency. But with a torch, you’re the dial: more chips, a longer burn, a longer rest under the top. Guys who like tinkering get more range out of the ComboJoy, especially with its 6 chip flavors to play with.

Round 4: Gift factor — ComboJoy wins

Gift box, two glasses, two ice ball molds, chips, torch. It unboxes like a full bar experience. The electric smoker is a cool gadget, but the ComboJoy looks like a present.

Round 5: Price and refills — ComboJoy wins

Price is in the same ballpark, but the ComboJoy packs in far more stuff for the money. Yes, you’ll buy butane on top of wood chips, but a can goes a long way. And with thousands more owner ratings, you know what you’re getting. The electric’s review pool is still small.

Get the ComboJoy   Check electric price

Who should buy which

Buy the ComboJoy if… you want the full kit, you’re buying a gift, or you like controlling the smoke yourself.

Buy the electric smoker if… you want zero butane and zero flame, you’re a total beginner, or you want the same result every pour with the timer.

Torch safety if you go ComboJoy

• Fill with proper butane in a ventilated spot, away from any flame.
• Never smoke near flammables, including napkins, paper and open high-proof bottles.
• Let the smoke top cool before touching or storing it.

The verdict

ComboJoy wins, 3 rounds to 2. The electric smoker is easier and safer for beginners, but the ComboJoy gives you more control, a far better gift box and a much bigger track record for similar money. Go electric only if a torch is a dealbreaker.

See the full lineup in our 10 best whiskey smoker kits, or read why the ComboJoy is a must-have.

Drink responsibly. 21+ only.